Insurance Recruiters
Build the best team with our insurance recruiting specialists
20+ Years Of Professional Insurance Recruiting
AllSearch Insurance Recruiters knows the industry.
Our insurance executive recruiters have a rich, 20-year internal network of talented professionals spanning the commercial and personal P&C realm, the agency world, and carriers and specialty insurers ranging from auto, marine, business, real estate, and even pets!
With nearly 20 years of operating as a premier insurance executive search firm, our client base runs the gamut from small to mid-size independent insurance agencies and brand name franchisees to industry co-ops and non-profits, and even some of the most well-known corporate firms in North America.
Alicia Smith leads the team as an experienced insurance industry recruiter. She spent several years working under a 20-year P&C insurance recruitment veteran, learning the industry —the lingo, the roles, and the companies — from the ground up.
Her dedication and proven success rates make her a natural fit to lead our insurance industry recruitment services team. Together, Alicia and her other hard-working insurance recruiting specialists are changing the game for job seekers and companies looking for their next hire.
Click button above to Request a No-Cost, No-Obligation Recruiting Consultation
How Do Our Insurance Executive Recruiters Find Skilled Talent?
Our unique combination of hands-on insurance experience and recruiting experience helps the AllSearch team rise above the competition, empowering our insurance recruiters to help you do the same in your search.
Here’s our approach to executive search:
1. Proactively sourcing the best insurance talent in the market.
Our insurance industry recruiters make new connections daily, getting to know the most seasoned and successful commercial property & casualty, claims, and account management executives in the insurance marketplace.
Leveraging those connections enables your recruiting partner to creatively source talent for an array of specializations, from insurance carriers and claims to underwriting and other agency-based companies.
2. Using a candidate pool that’s unique to AllSearch.
A large percentage of the candidates that we source are unique to our insurance industry database. With 18+ years of experience building thoughtful connections, our insurance industry recruitment services team can refer to a strategically curated list of active and passive talent to solicit hard-to-find referrals for our clients.
Our passive candidate list gives our recruiting partners an edge over their competitors. While they might not be actively looking for a new job, they are open to candid conversations with their long-time, trusted AllSearch insurance recruiter about that next great opportunity in the field.
3. Prioritizing quality hires over quantity.
Aligned perfectly with our mission, your AllSearch insurance recruiter works as an extension of your team. We’ll prioritize supplying you with the most well-matched candidates for the job, instead of just filling roles.
Some of our past clients have referred to us as “insurance headhunters” — a compliment we don’t take lightly!
Ready to Experience the AllSearch Recruiting Difference?
Insurance Recruitment Areas We Serve
Insurance Agency and Broker Positions
- Commercial Lines CSR – P&C Licensed
- Commercial Lines Account Manager – P&C Licensed
- Personal Lines CSR – P&C Licensed
- Personal Lines Account Manager – P&C Licensed
- Property & Casualty Producer
- Life & Health Producer
- Commercial Lines Manager
- Personal Lines Manager
- Agency Manager
- Account Manager – Employee Benefits
Carrier and Company Positions
- Commercial Underwriter
- Underwriting Manager – Commercial
- Underwriting Director – Commercial
- Human Resources Manager
- Personal Lines Underwriter
- Underwriting Manager – Personal
- Underwriting Director – Personal
- Territory Sales Rep – Carrier
- Accounting Manager
- Sales Manager – Carrier
- Sales Director – Carrier
- Claims Rep – P&C
- Claims Adjuster – P&C
- Claims Manager – P&C
- Workers’ Comp Claims Representative
"Kane is absolutely the BEST!!! He made my life changing event not so daunting. He truly is very good at what he does. A true gem!"
Place Your Trust In our top Insurance Recruiters
Our recruitment team has been building deep relationships with hundreds of small to mid-size insurance firms throughout America for 2 decades. We know the good firms, the ones to stay away from, and the positions that will lead you away from stagnation into a position of growth.
Plus, our insurance recruiters love what they do. “Build your career helping others build theirs” is one of the many mantras our recruiting professionals practice daily. Because if you don’t succeed, we don’t succeed either!
Work with an insurance recruiter who understands your goals and cares about making an impact in your world.
Find Your Path with AllSearch Recruiting!
NEWEST INSURANCE JOB OPENINGS
Our Insurance Recruiters
Honors and Awards
Insurance Industry Advice, Stories, Publications
the allsearch advantage
Eager to find the right recruiters to fulfill your hiring needs? Learn more about our insurance recruiting services below.
The Insurance Recruitment Division at AllSearch is led by Alicia Smith, a seasoned recruiting professional with extensive experience in the insurance industry.
As one of the leading insurance recruiting agencies, AllSearch specialized recruiters connect clients with elite talent for agency, broker, and carrier roles across commercial lines, personal lines, underwriting, claims, sales, and management. With over 18 years of deep industry immersion, our team serves as subject matter experts, proactively sourcing passive candidates from our exclusive database to deliver game-changing placements nationwide.
AllSearch insurance recruiters leverage hands-on industry expertise and proven talent acquisition strategies to source top-tier professionals in commercial property & casualty, claims adjusting, account management, underwriting, and agency operations. We proactively build daily connections with passive candidates, seasoned executives not responding to job ads, drawing from our exclusive 20+ year insurance talent database of active and hidden gems. This competitive edge in executive search delivers game-changing placements for carriers, brokers, and specialized insurance firms nationwide.
AllSearch specializes in insurance agency, broker, and carrier positions, including Commercial Lines CSR and Account Manager (P&C Licensed), Personal Lines CSR and Account Manager (P&C Licensed), Property & Casualty Producer, Life & Health Producer, Commercial and Personal Lines Managers, Agency Manager, and Account Manager for Employee Benefits. We also recruit for carrier roles such as Commercial and Personal Lines Underwriters, Underwriting Managers and Directors, Human Resources Manager, Territory Sales Rep, Accounting Manager, Sales Managers and Directors, Claims Rep and Adjuster (P&C), Claims Manager, and Workers’ Comp Claims Representative.