Insurance Recruiters
Build the best team with our insurance recruiting specialists
20+ Years Of Professional Insurance Recruiting
AllSearch Insurance Recruiters knows the industry.
With nearly 20 years of experience as a premier insurance executive search firm, AllSearch has built a rich internal network spanning commercial and personal P&C, independent agencies, carriers, specialty insurers, and everything in between—from auto and marine to real estate and pet insurance. Our client base ranges from small independent agencies and brand-name franchisees to industry co-ops, non-profits, and some of the most recognized corporate firms in North America.
Our insurance recruiting team is led by Alicia Smith, who learned the industry from the ground up under a seasoned 20-year P&C recruitment veteran—mastering the lingo, the roles, and the players before stepping up to lead the division herself. Together, Alicia and her team of insurance executive recruiters bring a hands-on, results-driven approach to every search, delivering better outcomes for both clients and candidates.
Click button above to Request a No-Cost, No-Obligation Recruiting Consultation
time-tested industry experience, powerful results
Years of Experience
Passive Candidate Pool
Countries of Global Reach
Our Process
Get Started
Share your hiring needs and tell us what your ideal candidate looks like.
Meet Your Recruiter
A dedicated staffing partner connects with you to dig into the details.
See Your Matches
We source, vet, and deliver a shortlist of top-tier candidates.
Interview & Select
We coordinate interviews and guide you through making the offer.
Start Strong
Bring your new hire on board with our support every step of the way.
Insurance Industries We Serve
- Independent Agencies
- Corporate Firms
- Franchises
- Industry Co-Ops
- Non-Profits
- Property & Casualty (P&C)
- Carriers
Insurance Agency and Broker Positions
- Commercial Lines CSR – P&C Licensed
- Commercial Lines Account Manager – P&C Licensed
- Personal Lines CSR – P&C Licensed
- Personal Lines Account Manager – P&C Licensed
- Property & Casualty Producer
- Life & Health Producer
- Commercial Lines Manager
- Personal Lines Manager
- Agency Manager
- Account Manager – Employee Benefits
Carrier and Company Positions
- Commercial Underwriter
- Underwriting Manager – Commercial
- Underwriting Director – Commercial
- Human Resources Manager
- Personal Lines Underwriter
- Underwriting Manager – Personal
- Underwriting Director – Personal
- Territory Sales Rep – Carrier
- Accounting Manager
- Sales Manager – Carrier
- Sales Director – Carrier
- Claims Rep – P&C
- Claims Adjuster – P&C
- Claims Manager – P&C
- Workers’ Comp Claims Representative
Newest Insurance Recruitment Job Openings
Industry News and Advice
By: Kyle Hullmann, Director of Business Development Artificial intelligence is no longer a trend in the recruiting industry; it’s a dominant force. We’ve passed the days of AI as simple
By: Mike Decker, Business Development Manager, Construction and Real Estate The modern construction industry is more complex than ever before: labor shortages, regulatory pressure, and technology adoption all impact the
By: Kyle Hullmann, Director of Business Development As the explosive growth of remote and hybrid work redefines workspaces across the globe, there’s more talent available than ever before. In this
Meet Our Team
Alicia Smith
Practice Lead & Sr. Recruiter - Insurance
Louis Moliterno
Professional Recruiter - Insurance
Cameron Eadie
Professional Recruiter - InsuranceTestimonials
Kane is absolutely the BEST!!! He made my life changing event not so daunting. He truly is very good at what he does. A true gem!
Matt has been instrumental in employee placement within our insurance agency throughout the last year and a half. I was personally contacted by Matt back in 2017 during my job search, and he set me up for an interview with the company I ended up joining. Matt helped me through each stage of the onboarding […]
the allsearch advantage
Looking for a top-tier recruiting solution for your company? Access answers to the most frequently asked questions for insurance recruiting services.
AllSearch Recruiting’s Insurance Recruitment Division is led by Alicia Smith, an experienced insurance industry recruiter who trained under a 20-year P&C recruitment veteran and has built a reputation for delivering results for both clients and candidates.
Typical Insurance Jobs We Recruit: Account Manager, Account Executive, Producer, Underwriter, Claims Adjuster, Risk Manager, Commercial Lines Manager, Personal Lines Manager, Agency Principal, Branch Manager, Client Services Manager, Loss Control Consultant, Surplus Lines Broker, Insurance Attorney, Compliance Officer, Executive Management
Our insurance executive recruiters work across a broad range of markets and disciplines, including commercial and personal P&C, independent agencies, brand-name franchisees, specialty insurers, carriers, and industry co-ops—giving us the depth to match the right talent to your specific corner of the industry.
Our insurance recruiting specialists move with urgency. On average, we source, screen, and deliver a curated shortlist of qualified candidates within a few weeks of kicking off a search, with regular updates keeping you informed throughout the process.
Honors & Awards
